Which ideal weight formula is the most accurate?
No single ideal weight formula is definitively the most accurate because each was developed for different populations and purposes. The Devine formula, created in 1974 for drug dosing calculations, is the most widely used but tends to underestimate healthy weight ranges for shorter individuals and overestimate for taller people. The Robinson and Miller formulas provide more moderate estimates that many clinicians consider more realistic. The BMI-based method using a target BMI of 22 offers the most individualized approach since it scales proportionally with height squared. Most modern healthcare providers in 2026 recommend using the BMI-based range of 18.5-24.9 rather than a single ideal weight number, as this accounts for natural variation in body frame, muscle mass, and bone density across different individuals.